Casey Key Real Estate

Casey Key Real Estate

Welcome to the prestigious subdivision of Casey Key, located in the beautiful state of Florida, specifically in Sarasota County within the charming cities of Osprey and Nokomis.

Casey Key is a hidden gem nestled between the sparkling waters of the Gulf of Mexico and the serene waters of the Intracoastal Waterway. This exclusive barrier island is renowned for its luxurious waterfront estates, pristine sandy beaches, and lush tropical landscapes, offering residents a tranquil and sophisticated coastal lifestyle.

Living in Casey Key means waking up to breathtaking sunrise views over the ocean, enjoying leisurely walks along secluded beaches, and experiencing unparalleled privacy and exclusivity. The community is a haven for those seeking a retreat from the hustle and bustle of city life, where the sounds of waves crashing against the shore provide the soundtrack to everyday living.

With easy access to Sarasota and its vibrant cultural scene, as well as proximity to upscale dining, shopping, and recreational activities, Casey Key offers the perfect balance of seclusion and convenience. Whether you are looking for a permanent residence or a vacation home, Casey Key presents a unique opportunity to own a piece of paradise in one of Florida's most coveted locations.

Discover the allure of Casey Key and experience luxury coastal living at its finest in this idyllic waterfront enclave.

Newest Listings in Casey Key

$6,500,000
5 Beds 3 Baths Casey Key SubDv. 34229 Zip Code
Rarely available Gulf to Bay estate size property with 175 feet of Gulf frontage, 175 feet of Bay frontage and encompassing 1.5 acres is located on the exclusive North End of Casey Key. Casey Key, distinguished for its absence of high-rises, traffic congestion, and private beaches, is one of the most esteemed barrier islands of Sarasota and Florida’s Gulf Coast. Positioned amidst exclusivity and privacy, this property presents a prime canvas for luxurious coastal living. Opportunity to build a spectacular new residence with no barriers to removing the current structure; or embrace “Old Florida” and restore the original house built in 1916. This building is the first and oldest structure built on Casey Key and was utilized as a “Fishing Lodge”. Uniquely the front of the house is oriented to Little Sarasota Bay because when it was built there were no bridges and the guests arrived and departed on boats from the mainland! Numerous infrastructure items have been completed facilitating a seamless progression for prospective owners. Most noteworthy is the successful approval and issuance of the permit by the State of Florida Department of Environmental Protection Agency to build west of the coastal construction line, which allows for a 6600+ square foot two-story single-family residence, a 1600+ square foot one-story detached accessory structure with bonus suite, swimming pool, and a reflecting pond at the entrance of the main residence. This is significant because the State EPA permit is the most difficult permit to obtain; also, the Sarasota County building permits are currently in process. The impressive new dock is constructed with premium composite decking and sturdy pilings, which accommodates various vessel sizes, including a 40,000-pound boat lift for vessels over 40 feet, a 17,000-pound lift for boats ranging from 25 to 37 feet, plus a double wave runner lift. Extending 162 feet into the bay, the dock offers power and water access throughout its length, alongside amenities like a fish cleaning station and other conveniences. Additionally, the newly drilled 4-inch and 400-foot-deep irrigation well assures that the estate grounds will be a lush and tropical environment. Embracing the island lifestyle, residents relish the warm Gulf breezes by day and breathtaking sunsets at dusk. A favorite transportation choice by residents is often Golf Carts with easy access to nearby tiki bars, restaurants, grocery store, pharmacy and more. The property's strategic location just north of the historic Blackburn Point bridge facilitates excellent proximity to the mainland with top-rated schools, fine dining establishments, Downtown Sarasota, St Armand’s Circle, The Island of Venice, and world-class medical facilities. Notably, Casey Key is the ONLY barrier island in the region with an expressway from Tamiami Trail to I75 creating easy access to all area international airports, plus private air travel options within ten minutes. The allure of this locale is undeniable, as Casey Key Road was recently acclaimed as the most impressive street nationwide, underscoring the unparalleled status of this magical barrier island.

608 N Casey Key Road, Osprey

$6,500,000
Casey Key SubDv. 34229 Zip Code
Rarely available Gulf to Bay estate size property with 175 feet of Gulf frontage, 175 feet of Bay frontage and encompassing 1.5 acres is located on the exclusive North End of Casey Key. Casey Key, distinguished for its absence of high-rises, traffic congestion, and private beaches, is one of the most esteemed barrier islands of Sarasota and Florida’s Gulf Coast. Positioned amidst exclusivity and privacy, this property presents a prime canvas for luxurious coastal living. Numerous infrastructure items have been completed facilitating a seamless progression for prospective owners. Most noteworthy is the successful approval and issuance of the permit by the State of Florida Department of Environmental Protection Agency to build west of the coastal construction line, which allows for a 6600+ square foot two-story single-family residence, a 1600+ square foot one-story detached accessory structure with bonus suite, swimming pool, and a reflecting pond at the entrance of the main residence. This is significant because the State EPA permit is the most difficult permit to obtain; also, the Sarasota County building permits are currently in process. The impressive new dock is constructed with premium composite decking and sturdy pilings, which accommodates various vessel sizes, including a 40,000-pound boat lift for vessels over 40 feet, a 17,000-pound lift for boats ranging from 25 to 37 feet, plus a double wave runner lift. Extending 162 feet into the bay, the dock offers power and water access throughout its length, alongside amenities like a fish cleaning station and other conveniences. Additionally, the newly drilled 4-inch and 400-foot-deep irrigation well assures that the estate grounds will be a lush and tropical environment. Embracing the island lifestyle, residents relish the warm Gulf breezes by day and breathtaking sunsets at dusk. A favorite transportation choice by residents is often Golf Carts with easy access to nearby tiki bars, restaurants, grocery store, pharmacy and more. The property's strategic location just north of the historic Blackburn Point bridge facilitates excellent proximity to the mainland with top-rated schools, fine dining establishments, Downtown Sarasota, St Armand’s Circle, The Island of Venice, and world-class medical facilities. Notably, Casey Key is the ONLY barrier island in the region with an expressway from Tamiami Trail to I75 creating easy access to all area international airports, plus private air travel options within ten minutes. The allure of this locale is undeniable, as Casey Key Road was recently acclaimed as the most impressive street nationwide, underscoring the unparalleled status of this magical barrier island. Please note the original house built in 1916, which is the first and oldest homestead built on Casey Key, is still on the property; however, there are no barriers to removing the structure.

608 N Casey Key Road, Osprey

$6,890,000
4 Beds 6.5 Baths Casey Key SubDv. 34275 Zip Code
Indulge in the essence of coastal luxury at this exquisite three-story estate on Casey Key. Along the Gulf Coast, this home offers a seamless blend of elegance and comfort, with each floor presenting a unique experience. Step outside and feel the soft sand at your feet, as this property boasts 100 feet of beach on the gulf. The second floor serves as the heart of the home, featuring the main living spaces accessible by elevator or the grand staircase. The chef's kitchen is adorned with neutral wood cabinetry, granite countertops, stainless steel Thermador appliances, and a walk-in pantry. Tile floors add a touch of sophistication, while the open living room boasts two-story ceilings and oversized windows offering stunning Gulf of Mexico views. The kitchen and great room conveniently open to the patio and lanai featuring a pool with travertine pool deck and additional decking making it the ideal indoor-outdoor venue for lounging or a quick refreshing swim. Remote-controlled screens enclose the pool area for added comfort and convenience. The primary suite on this floor is complete with high ceilings, crown molding, and private access to a balcony shared with the living room accentuating water and sunset views. The en-suite bath features a walk-in shower with frameless shower walls, a spacious vanity with two sinks, an oversized, custom walk-in closet and a linen closet. A powder room and an oversized storage closet complete the offerings on this floor. Elevator access or the grand staircase takes you to the third floor, where a landing seating area and kitchenette with a beverage cooler, sink, microwave and storage closet add convenience. This level boasts a second primary suite, mirroring the elegance of the main suite on the level below. The guest suite on this level offers amazing Gulf of Mexico views from the private balcony, a spacious closet and an en-suite bath with a vanity, tub and shower, and linen closet. The spacious yard area with a boardwalk leading to the beach may be accessed from the second level or the ground level. The lush Florida landscape, full of palm trees and sea grapes, is a serene oasis. Additionally, there is a separate guest casita that includes a kitchen with a range, refrigerator, sink, pantry and plenty of cabinet and counter space. The open living and dining area, spacious bedroom with access to the lanai and a full bath make this casita the ideal retreat for guests. The ground floor of the main house also offers a spacious laundry room along with tons of storage and bonus space. Experience the ultimate beachfront living at this stunning Gulf Coast estate, where every detail is designed for elegance and comfort.

955 Casey Key Road, Nokomis

$4,495,000
4 Beds 3 Baths Casey Key SubDv. 34275 Zip Code
Indulge in the epitome of coastal luxury at this remarkable Casey Key beachfront residence, boasting unparalleled panoramic gulf front views. Step onto the expansive rear paver patio and witness dolphins playfully frolicking in the surf. Soak in the breathtaking unobstructed sunsets visible from numerous rooms within this thoughtfully designed open floor plan home. Seamlessly connecting the living room, family room, dining room and kitchen, this home creates an inviting space for entertaining and relaxation. Tile flooring throughout the first floor, 9-foot ceilings and large impact sliding glass doors frame the picturesque views of the gulf, evoking a sense of tranquility and awe. The kitchen, a chef's delight, features white cabinets with pullout shelves, stainless steel appliances, tile backsplash and an abundance of countertops, including a gas cooktop. Adjacent to the kitchen, a breakfast nook with sliding glass doors offers easy access to the patio, ideal for enjoying morning coffee while taking in the scenic surroundings. For those seeking a quiet retreat or a dedicated workspace, the office features double-entry glass pane French doors, ceiling fan and recessed built-in shelving. The primary owner’s suite exudes comfort and luxury, with sliding glass doors leading to a spacious private balcony overlooking the beach and sparkling gulf waters. A large walk-in closet and en-suite bath with dual vanities, soaking garden tub and walk-in tile shower ensure a serene retreat. Guests will feel pampered in the generously sized bedrooms, each offering private access to a Jack-and-Jill bath. The fourth bedroom, on the ground floor and distinct from the communal spaces, features direct bath access and its own private exterior entry, making it an ideal in-law or guest suite, or even a media room. Updates include new HVAC units in 2024, impact windows, doors and exterior siding in 2020, a metal roof in 2015, and a tankless water heater in 2017 to offer convenience and peace of mind. Being on the water is not complete without boat access, and the captain in you will relish the convenience of the deeded boat dock just steps away on the intracoastal. The voluminous three-car garage includes an additional climate-controlled room, ideal for a workshop, art studio, workout room or just extra storage. Appreciate the convenience of having the nationally acclaimed Pine View school, ranked #18 in the country, just a short 15-minute drive away. In an ideal location with convenient bridge access to shopping, dining and amenities, this gulf front property epitomizes the ultimate coastal lifestyle. Don’t miss your chance to own this extraordinary coastal retreat. Schedule your showing today!

409 Casey Key Road, Nokomis

$3,200,000
3 Beds 3.5 Baths Casey Key SubDv. 34229 Zip Code
DROP ANCHOR and stay forever in this 3 bedroom, 3.5 bath, intracoastal waterway home tucked away just enough to feel like you have your very own private oasis. You have deeded boat access with your own assigned boat slip where you may catch dolphins playing in the water before you take out your kayaks, jet skis, or the boat. Across the street you also have deeded Gulf of Mexico access where you can watch the most stunning sunsets painted across the sky! Brand new engineered hardwood floors in the family room and the primary bedroom. The upstairs bedroom has a private balcony overlooking the BRAND NEW infinity pool and the intracoastal waterway. The primary bedroom also has amazing intracoastal waterway views. New deck with composite All Weather decking.The kitchen is open concept with gorgeous stainless appliances. The loft overlooks the living area. The kitchen and living room have vaulted ceilings. This home has a security system. Your driveway and parking area is relatively large, You're a short distance from some of the best restaurants in the area! This home sits on a beautifully landscaped oversized lot right on the intracoastal on the highly desired, gorgeous, and coveted island of North Casey Key. While the house is beautiful, if it’s not your style, you could simply remodel, built up another level, or tear down the entire home so that you can build the home of your dreams! Current owner has architectural plans for an addition that can be left for you. Current owner also has the additional security and home monitoring (*working alongside the Sarasota police), for those who live on the island for a small fee. Seller is also offering a concession to help you pay down your interest rate. Whether you purchase this home for entertainment or relaxation, you need to schedule a viewing.

140 N Casey Key Road, Osprey

$11,795,000
5 Beds 6.5 Baths Casey Key SubDv. 34275 Zip Code
Auction Property. AUCTION: Bid 5–18 June | Listed for $11.795M | No Reserve | Starting Bids Expected Between $3M-$6M | Showings Sat & Sun 12-3 PM & by appointment This exquisite property sits on 90 feet of beachfront along the pristine Gulf Coast of Florida in the exclusive Casey Key neighborhood. This gorgeous mansion features a Spanish-style exterior and Old World touches inside with iron details, a grand staircase, and stone columns. Every ceiling features a step, trey, or coffered ceiling. Beautiful floor-to-ceiling windows bathe the main living areas in natural light. The gourmet kitchen has eye-catching countertops, wooden cabinets, and high-end appliances. Two primary suites with private balconies, sitting areas, and lavish baths are the height of luxurious living. In addition to the spacious interior, the exterior offers tons of room to entertain. The pool and spa are surrounded by a beautiful travertine deck with a nearby gas grill and bar. Stroll down the beautiful dunewalk to access the beach or enjoy a movie night in the media room. This stunning home combines elegant features and modern amenities to create the ultimate tropical haven. The exterior provides a mosquito-repellent system surrounding the perimeter of the home. Ease of entry and exit with a circular paver driveway leading to a porte-cochere, and side entry three-car garage with extra storage room for kayaks and canoes to use at the deeded bay access that comes with this home. For peace of mind and comfort, this home was built to hurricane codes in 2008 with all impact windows and doors, a full reverse osmosis water system, industrial long-lasting gas generator, 1,000-gallon propane tank and an aerobic septic tank system with a newer drain field. A large walkable beach to the north and south, close to great restaurants, a marina with boat storage close by, and just a short drive to downtown Sarasota makes this beachfront home on the secluded and unrivaled tropical haven of Casey Key the unique property you have been waiting for.

507 Casey Key Road, Nokomis

$4,100,000
4 Beds 3.5 Baths Casey Key SubDv. 34229 Zip Code
Welcome to your very own Gulf front beach home located on one of the most captivating, serene and exclusive barrier islands on Florida's west coast. This custom 4 bedroom 3.5 bathroom mid-century modern luxury property is directly on the Gulf with absolutely stunning unobstructed views and your very own private beach. Relax in the sun on the patio or take in the gorgeous sunsets from almost every room. You'll love the open living area with large ceramic tiles throughout, vaulted exposed beam ceilings, fireplace and dining room that adjoins the beautiful kitchen. The kitchen features lovely quartz countertops and stainless appliances. The beach carries indoors with the charm and character of local beach shells crushed and floated in natural cement to create textured walls that brings the outside indoors. Listen to the waves as you fall asleep in your upper level primary suite with gorgeous water views and maximum privacy for both owners and guests. The peaceful bedrooms also include a second primary suite on the first floor. The gated entry onto the property brings you into complete privacy and seclusion with lush landscaping and large shade trees. Enjoy sitting in the shade of the magnificent live oak around the fountain on your over 1/2 acre lot. Take a walk or drive your golf cart to the famous Casey Key Fish House and Deep Lagoon upscale restaurant and marina, only a half mile to the supermarket, and a quick drive to all of the wonderful shops and restaurants Sarasota and Venice has to offer. Easy access to the mainland and I-75 via the iconic Blackburn Point Bridge nearby.

5 N Casey Key Road, Osprey

$8,500,000
4 Beds 4.5 Baths Casey Key SubDv. 34275 Zip Code
Nestled along the pristine shores of Casey Key, this luxurious residence optimizes coastal living at its finest. Boasting breathtaking panoramic views of the Gulf of Mexico, this 4-bedroom, 4.5-bathroom plus pool room with full bath, home is a masterpiece of architectural design and opulent comfort. Upon entering, guests are greeted by an elegant foyer leading to a spacious living area adorned with floor-to-ceiling windows and balcony, allowing natural light to cascade throughout the space and offering uninterrupted vistas of the turquoise waters beyond. The open-concept layout seamlessly connects the living room, dining area, and gourmet kitchen, creating an ideal setting for entertaining or simply enjoying tranquil evenings with loved ones. The kitchen is a chef's dream, featuring top-of-the-line appliances, custom cabinetry, and a center island with bar seating. Adjacent to the kitchen is an inclusive dining area, perfect for enjoying morning coffee while soaking in the breathtaking views or entertaining guests for dinner parties. For added convenience, an elevator provides easy access to all levels of the home, ensuring accessibility for residents and guests alike. The master suite, located on the main floor, is a sanctuary unto itself, complete with a spa-like bathroom featuring a walk-in shower, dual vanities, and a walk-in closet. With floor to ceiling picture windows, waking to the serene views is easy with remote shades for optimal relaxation and resting. On the second floor, you'll discover three additional bedroom suites, each providing serene havens. One suite could be a second master suite with soaking tub, dual vanity, and walk-in shower and closet that provide a private escape of expansive coastal views. Adjacent to these bedrooms, a family room awaits, ideal for hosting gatherings or unwinding in comfort. Step out onto the expansive balcony and immerse yourself in the soothing melody of waves crashing against the shore, enhancing the atmosphere of relaxation and tranquility. The expansive outdoor living space is an entertainer's paradise, featuring a sparkling salt water heated pool and spa overlooking the Gulf, a spacious deck for sunbathing, and a putting green for golf enthusiasts. Outdoor kitchen by the pool area and on the main level makes it easy to entertain in both areas watching the award winning sunsets of Casey Key. The pool room with dishwasher, sink, ice maker, and refrigerator plus full bath makes after pool or beach fun easily cleaned up and not tracked through the main home. Full feature sheet attached as the upgrades are endless! With its unparalleled location, luxurious amenities, and unparalleled views, this Casey Key residence offers a rare opportunity to experience coastal living at its absolute finest. Whether as a full-time residence or a vacation retreat, this magnificent home is sure to exceed even the most discerning buyer's expectations.

3801 Casey Key Road, Nokomis

$2,140,000
5 Beds 3 Baths Casey Key SubDv. 34275 Zip Code
One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. IT'S ALWAYS ALL ABOUT THE LOCATION! Casey Key is a very private narrow barrier island located just North of Venice FL and South of Siesta Key; it separates the intracostal waterway and the Gulf of Mexico. The Key is home to some of the most luxurious waterfront Estates and Mansions in the Sarasota area. This large ½ acre Bayfront lot is peacefully set back from any traffic on Casey Key Road. The dock is on the North side of the property on a canal protected from wind and waves. From the living room or the Bay-side deck, views of the intracoastal waterway and its many traveling boats and yachts are stunning. Take a short 100 yard stroll down your deeded beach easement, to the pristine sands of the Gulf of Mexico. The beach is very private, ideal for swimming, snorkeling, sunbathing, shark tooth hunting, or just viewing the beautiful sunsets. The main floor houses 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths, the kitchen and the dining room. The first floor has one full bath and 3 rooms that can be used as bedrooms, rec room, den, etc. Other amenities include swimming pool, shuffle board court, elevator, and two single car garages. A new roof was installed in 2019. Live in the house "as is" or convert it to the home of your dreams located in paradise. Note: Some images have been virtually staged to better showcase the true potential of rooms and spaces in the home.

1210 Casey Key Road, Nokomis

$3,750,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Casey Key SubDv. 34275 Zip Code
Uncover an unparalleled opportunity to claim your own slice of paradise on the coveted shores of Casey Key with this exceptional Gulf-to-bay property. Nestled amidst the serene beauty of the island, this property offers the perfect blend of tranquility and luxury. Step into a charming two-bedroom, two-bath beach cottage exuding warmth and character. Adorned with pecky cypress siding and featuring a cozy brick fireplace, this home offers a welcoming retreat from the world. The vintage cottage has been impeccably maintained and is ready for immediate occupancy, allowing you to start enjoying the coastal lifestyle from day one. With one bedroom downstairs and one bedroom upstairs, the split plan layout offers privacy and convenience for you and your guests. Benefit from modern comforts with two new AC units installed in 2024, ensuring year-round comfort, a roof replaced in 2015 for added peace of mind, and the convenience of an interior laundry room. Indulge in stunning vistas of the Gulf of Mexico and the Intracoastal Waterway from every angle. Whether you're lounging in the living room or relaxing on the rooftop deck, the panoramic views will never cease to captivate. A private walkway leads you directly to your own sandy beach along the Gulf of Mexico, offering exclusive access to the tranquil waters and pristine shores. Situated on Casey Key's natural eight-mile barrier island, this property offers unparalleled waterfront living. With nearby amenities including shopping, dining, golf, and easy access to private air travel at the Venice airport, every convenience is at your fingertips. This Gulf-to-bay property presents an unparalleled opportunity to create your dream beach retreat on Casey Key's coveted shores. Whether you choose to embrace the vintage charm of the existing cottage or envision a custom-designed masterpiece, the value lies in the land, offering endless possibilities for you to craft your bespoke sanctuary by the sea. Don't miss out on the chance to make this picturesque setting your own and experience the ultimate in waterfront living on Casey Key. Schedule your private viewing today and seize the opportunity to turn your coastal dreams into reality!

1620 Casey Key Road, Nokomis

Start Your Search